A friend wrote to me about a friend of his and asked me for advice. He wrote, “I saw a childhood friend over the weekend … he comes from very solid Christian parents and grew up in the church, but doesn’t believe anymore. His main issue is that no one can answer his question where dinosaurs came from before the Garden of Eden and ultimately before the earth was made. He says if someone was able to answer this, it would really help him.”

So, I responded:

I hope this is helpful for your friend. It sounds like he was raised with a literalistic view of Genesis being six literal days. If so, I understand his dilemma. Hopefully, this will help him look beyond his old Sunday School classes :-). It is a big topic and one that is debated. I will try not to be too wordy and complicated, but also not too simple to insult his intelligence.

There are those who hold a literal six days of creation that took place 6,000 years ago and thus we have a “young earth.” Other Christians hold a view that God created over a long period of time and the “days” of Genesis refer to time periods and explained in a way that pre-scientific people could understand.

Intelligent design means that even though God may have used evolutionary processes to develop the world, nature and man, it was done over time by his design, not by chance.

God has two books: 1) he wrote nature which we can “read” and 2) he wrote Divine Revelation in Scripture and Tradition which we can also read. Since he is truth his two “books” cannot contradict each other so science and revelation, faith and reason, are not opposed to each other. Divine Revelation explains the why and Natural Revelation (science) tries to explain the how.

Assuming as most Catholics do, that God created over a period of time, it takes scientific discovery into account. There have been ice ages and periods of a warm earth. This is why the whole global warming agenda today is silly since these cycles have happened throughout the earth’s long history without man and there is very little man can do to cause them now. We know there were times the earth was very warm because we find warm-blooded creatures frozen under the ice in the north. So, we have to take science into account and figure out how science and revelation fit together.

Having said that, even in the Genesis creation account, man is created last as God’s masterpiece. Already in the early days of creation there were plants and animals. We are not told the kind or names of the animals, only that there were those that flew, swam, walked and crept about. We assume that the animals are those that we know today, but there could very well have been at one time or another dinosaurs and other creatures that preceded man.

 Hairy mammoths and other extinct animals have been found in the ice and also dinosaur bones and fossils. It is no problem for a Christian who looks at science and the Bible to say, “God worked over time and there were stages and phases to the process of creation. There was a time before man was actually created in the likeness of God that dinosaurs roamed the earth.” What happened to wipe them out is a whole other discussion.

What we as Catholics (and other Christians) must believe is that God created everyone out of nothing (ex nihilism) by his power. Second, that “life” was a unique creation of God and third, that at one point in time God created man and woman as a uniqued creation and embed them with his own likeness and image with an eternal soul. How and when that happened is left open for discussion.

What any person would be foolish to do is deny God’s existence because if there is no personal infinite God then we are all just a random process of chemicals, time, chance and matter. In this case there is no meaning or purpose to existence and someday it will all collapse in on itself and it will be over, just one big meaningless nightmare.

Or to believe that a God exists and to ignore him is to be foolish and miss out on the great adventure of knowing him and learning about his creation and deeper life and the ultimate meaning and love of God.

Below are a Catechism quote, two paragraphs from my new book on Genesis, and a few links to other sites that might be helpful for your friend. Also a chart I made up to help our kids understand (when they were young) about the two possible views of how we got here. It is called “You are a Detective”.
1) Catechism quote:
The Catholic Catechism says, “God himself created the visible world in all its richness, diversity, and order. Scripture presents the work of the Creator symbolically as a succession of six days of divine “work,” concluded by the “rest” of the seventh day. On the subject of creation, the sacred text teaches the truths revealed by God for our salvation, permitting us to “recognize the inner nature, the value, and the ordering of the whole of creation to the praise of God.” Nothing exists that does not owe its existence to God the Creator. The world began when God’s word drew it out of nothingness; all existent beings, all of nature, and all human history are rooted in this primordial event, the very genesis by which the world was constituted and time begun.”  Paragraphs 337, 338  Catholic Church, Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd Ed. (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997), 87–88.
2) Here are two paragraphs from my new book on Genesis: Creation or Evolution?

Ever since Darwin published his Origin of Species in 1859, there has been a flurry of discussion among Christians about how this impacts an understanding of the creation accounts in Genesis. The Catholic Church perceives no conflict between legitimate science and religion because both seek the truth. God is Truth, and truth will never contradict the Truth. In other words, both creation (natural revelation) and Scripture (special revelation) have God as their author, therefore they cannot be in contradiction with each other. Catholics are therefore free to believe that an evolutionary process was used by God, and they are not obliged to adhere to a literal six 24-hour day creation. These theories relate to the process of creation, not the origin of creation.

What Catholics must believe is that in the beginning, God created everything ex nihilo, out of nothing (CCC 296-298; 318). Catholics are obliged to believe that God created life, and that man’s spiritual soul was and is created immediately by God (CCC 382). A Catholic cannot hold that matter existed eternally, or that it was a matter of chance that brought about a process of evolution. Additionally, Catholics cannot hold that the soul of man evolved or was derived from the parents; Catholic teaching informs us that man’s spiritual soul was and is a direct and conscious creation of God and is eternal (CCC 366). God infused an immortal soul into Man, and as a result, Man is created in the image of God. Whether you consider that Man was created instantly or by a process of divine evolution—in either case, God directly creates the soul and infuses it into each person, and thereby confers incredible dignity on Mankind.

3) A few more detailed websites that may be helpful in case your friend is interested in diving in to read more.
A short audio about how do dinosaurs fit in. Click the link and then scroll down and click on the time code 48:03 https://www.catholic.com/audio/cal/cal-7984
4) My chart “You are a Detective”

This Post Has 3 Comments

  1. john

    What I find fascinating is the interplay between body and soul. If humans evolved from prior species (as overwhelming evidence suggests), at what point were we infused with souls? Did our pre-modern human ancestors have souls going all the way up the chain of evolution? Was there a time when children had souls but their parents did not? Or was there a moment parents received a soul, meaning they were born without souls? Did other subspecies of humans – Neanderthals, Java men, a small but significant portion of whose DNA we share – also have souls? And what of other species who derived from our common ancestors? Were they not infused with souls before our lateral separations? If our souls did not evolve with us and were a constant throughout evolution, it still begs the question of timing. Perhaps all animals have souls? We hold that not to be true but it’s hard to understand how souls could always have been while humans have not. Obviously, nobody gave any of these considerations any thought at the time the Bible was written. It’s definitely a conundrum.

    STEVE RAY HERE: The Church teaches that animals do have a natural soul which animates their body. The distinction is that human beings have a rational or spiritual soul which not only animates their body but also makes them immortal and eternal. Interesting discussion indeed.

  2. Arthur R Adams

    In addition to what Steve said, we have to accept that there are many things we do not understand. Remember, God is omnipotent and our human minds are not able to really grasp creation or the fact that God is outside time. Additionally, always remember that the biggest problem with science is that science does not know what it does not know, and so has limitations; this is why research continues. For example, before radio waves were discovered, it was the scientific position that they did not exist. We accept what we cannot know by the gift of faith given to us by God. One day, all this will be revealed to us.

    STEVE RAY HERE: Nicely said Arthur. Thanks.

  3. Steve Pruner

    One needs to answer a more fundamental question: when did death enter in to creation? Was it was before or after man had sinned? If man was not created in those 6 literal days and death was in creation before man, then death was created by God. [sic[ That is absurd! To say that the earth is millions of years old and man came later., is to say that death was in the world preexistant to man.

Comments are closed.