Time to Excommunicate! Canon Lawyer Ed Peters weighs in on Pro-abort politicians

by Steve Ray on January 25, 2019

Canon 915’s moment has arrived

January 25, 2019  by Dr. Ed Peters

andrew-cuomo-ny-governorGov. Andrew Cuomo’s blatant promotion of New York’s horrid abortion law seems to have been a tipping point.

Demands, demands, that Catholic leaders do something serious to confront unbridled abortionism in the ranks of Catholic politicos are being published like I’ve never seen them urged in four decades of watching such things. To that authentic Catholic sense, right at so many levels, I give nothing but an Amen. Here’s my only concern: Catholics at various stations in the Church, most largely untrained in canon law (no shame in that, that’s what five decades of pervasive ecclesial antinomianism will get you), are making, whether they know it or not, demands for canonical actions in Cuomo’s regard, which actions might or (more likely) might not be possible under current canon law and, having missed their mark, will wrongly conclude that canon law offers no remedies in the face of Cuomo-like conduct. I refer specifically to calls for the formal excommunication of Andrew Cuomo, but the issues in this case are applicable to other cases on the near horizon.

So, first and foremost, and setting aside Richard Burton’s Abp. Becket stentoriously excommunicating enemies of the Church from the cathedral high altar, excommunication is today what it has always essentially been, a canonical penalty that can be meted out only in accord with canon law. As a canonical sanction, the application of excommunication requires, at a minimum, (1) a law in place that prohibits, under pain of excommunication, a given action, (2) accessibility to facts sufficient to demonstrate the guilt of an individual accused of doing such an act, and (3) an independent process to interpret the law and apply it correctly to the facts at hand. See Canons 18 and 221, and most of Books VI and VII of the 1983 Code.

partialbirthabortionThose who think that Andrew Cuomo should be excommunicated for signing New York’s appalling abortion law need no invitation to make their case for that canonical sanction in accord with the canon law. Thomas Becket could make his case for excommunication (the curious and Latin-literate can verify that claim by checking, say, Gasparri’s footnotes to 1917 CIC 2343 § 4, provisions that took a dim view of murdering priests). But, if moderns cannot make the case for Cuomo’s excommunication (and I, among many others trained in canon law, do not think they can), they should cease calling for the (presently) impossible and focus instead on what can (and I, along with some notable others, think should) be done in the face of a Cuomo-like affront to Church teaching and basic human dignity.

Fine, but what?

Consider: the single most publicly-observable aspect of excommunication (hardly surprising, given the very name of this sanction) is, of course, exclusion from holy Communion. Whatever other sacramental and disciplinary consequences are visited upon an excommunicate (and those consequences are several and significant, per Canon 1331), what is most obvious to the individual, to the faith community, and to the general public, is that an excommunicate isbarred from participating in the Church’s greatest sacrament, holy Communion (Canons 915 and 1331). This public barring prevents sacrilege from being committed against the Sacrament, mitigates the scandal inflicted on the faith community when patently unworthy Catholics pretend to a communion in faith belied by their deeply contrarian actions, and alerts the world that the Church is serious about securing upright witness in her own ranks.

Now, here’s the point: all of the personal, community, and even secular values served by barring an excommunicate from holy Communion as part of the sanction of excommunication areimmediately available simply by applying Canon 915a sacramental disciplinary norm in Book IV of the Code (and not a penal norm from Book VI), which canon requires ministers of holy Communion to withhold the Sacrament, not just from those under formal sanction, of course, but also from those who ‘obstinately persevere in manifest grave sin’. Let that phrasing sink in.

Applying Canon 915, moreover, is not constrained by narrowly-drawn definitions of crimes and/or cooperation therein, it does not rely on loophole-ridden latae sententiae procedures (a canonical relic that today is mostly useful for letting bishops avoid making hard decisions), and it does not continue the rampant disregard for the rule of law in the Church seen over the last 50 years (mostly by figures, I grant, themselves none too concerned about human conduct and the rightful role of the Church in shaping it, and so, in that respect, distinguishable from those lately calling for Cuomo’s excommunication).

Instead, Canon 915 enables, indeed requires, prompt (not precipitous, but prompt) action by ministers to protect the Most August Sacrament from abuse, to alert an individual about his or her morally gravely dangerous public conduct, to protect the faith community from scandal, and to give serious witness to the world about the importance of Church teaching to Church members. Are these not the key goals sought by those calling for Cuomo’s (and some others’) excommunication? If so, why try to purse those goals with a cumbersome penal institute such as excommunication when Canon 915 is sitting right in front of us?

In short, has not Canon 915’s moment, at last, arrived?

For the rest of the article click here.

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Sandi January 26, 2019 at 12:07 PM

Amen. Yes, it is time. Those who profess to be Catholics, MUST be prevented from receiving Holy Communion for advocating and celebrating abortion. It is an abomination.

Note to Steve: The back and forth movement of the right side of your home page is distracting and makes reading articles difficult.

JoAnne McCormack January 27, 2019 at 7:12 AM

It is past time that the Church do something about these blatantly evil actions by some politicians who claim to be Catholic. What Cuomo has done is beyond horrific and is certainly not in accord with Church teaching. He is a “Blind Guide” leading others to mortal sin and thus should be excommunicated. Nancy Pelosi also claims to be a “practicing Catholic and supports abortion as well. And there are many others. I believe many of our bishops have become weak and “politically correct” and are afraid to take action, while others have become so liberal as to ignore Jesus’s teaching. This does not bode well for them or the Church. I pray the Holy Spirit will guide our bishops and our Holy Father to do the right thing. Things have been too loosely -goosey for far too long. Time to get back to realizing that although the Lord is Mercy itself, He is also Just, and we will all have to stand before Him on Judgement Day. Time to repent and take action now. How many more precious babies will be murdered because of Cuomo ‘s new law?Jesus said “Repent, and believe the Good News!” I believe it is time we all do so, including the Church.

Tom Govern January 27, 2019 at 10:32 PM

So tired of our Church leaders not standing up to those “Catholics” that proclaim abortion. It is a non-negotiable. Our bishops have let us down in the name of attaining some sort of peace. Jesus through usury people out of the Temple, think of what he would have done (and will do) with abortionists. It is time that our Church actually practiced what it preaches through the actions of its leaders.

Padre January 28, 2019 at 5:57 PM

Dr Peter’s,

It seems that although you are correct that their is no canonical crime of promoting abortion, this mater could still fall under that catchall of Can 1399


Can. 1399 Besides the cases prescribed in this or in other laws, the external violation of divine or canon law can be punished, and with a just penalty, only when the special gravity of the violation requires it and necessity demands that scandals be prevented or repaired.

Here it seems clear that there is AT LEAST a crime against Divine Law, which has “specisl gravity… [that] requires it…

And it seems a commonly held opinion that the just penalty would be excommunication, which as you note practically speaking has the same effect as proper application of Can 915

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: